The knowledge deficit: closing the shocking education gap for American children
EdCentral community rating

Add to my reading list
Dr Eric D Hirsch, Jr

Dr Hirsch claims that although schools are teaching the mechanics of reading, they fail to convey the knowledge needed for the more complex and essential skill of reading comprehension. Hirsch corrects popular misconceptions about topical issues in education, such as standardised testing, and takes to task educators' claims that they are powerless to overcome class differences.

He asserts that the problem with US education is not inadequate teachers; rather, it is a set of misguided ideas in which teachers have been taught to believe, such as naturalism or the notion that learning should proceed from experience rather than formal education.  He also disputes formalism, or the notion that schools should attempt to teach generalisable skills, such as inferring and information gathering, rather than bodies of content knowledge; and, demographic determinism, the idea that teaching alone cannot overcome the achievement differences that result from socioeconomic inequality.

Hirsch argues that schools need to spend more time on academic content and a common base of knowledge.  If this is taught to pupils at a very early age, it will have huge long-term effects not only on their individual reading comprehension, but on closing the inequality gap, since this is where disadvantaged pupils need the most help.

In listing research, EdCentral makes no judgment or recommendation as to its quality, validity or methodology and none should be inferred. Through peer ratings left by education practitioners, EdCentral’s aim is to support the development of a repository of shared knowledge and experience.

*   Please note that your reading list can only be saved permanently if you are logged into your account.

Dr Eric D Hirsch, Jr

Published by:
Mariner Books

Date of publication:
January 2006

Country of origin:

CPD opportunities:

This book sets out the need for pupils to be taught a core academic curriculum from an early age, and argues that doing so will help literacy and close the inequality gap. It may be of particular use to primary school teachers and policy makers. 


Record ID:
R290 / 394
Rating Summary:

0 based on 0 votes

Start a discussion

Back to search results   |   New search   |   View my reading list   |   Print this page

EdCentral Logo